11 Answers 11 Sorted by:
Usually, lasagna needs to cook for about 30 minutes in a hot oven. As others in this thread have pointed out, the primary issue is pasta sheets’ propensity to dry out when exposed to high temperatures for extended periods of time.
I usually precook the sheets for one minute in slightly salted boiling water to avoid this; the goal is to soften the sheets, not cook them. A few drops of oil in the boiling water should also help prevent the sheets from sticking to one another. Then, as I work on making the sauces, I drain the sheets and place them on a fresh cotton cloth to absorb the cooking water.
Once the lasagne is assembled in the pan, I cover it with aluminum foil and bake it for 20 minutes. After that, I take off the foil and allow the lasagne to cook for an additional 10 minutes “naked.”
Here are some pictures I took during the preparation of lasagne with crumbled sausages and mushrooms.
By using this method, the majority of the moisture is retained in the lasagna sheets, so they don’t require as much sauce to stay hydrated.
Even using Sainsbury’s Value Lasagne Sheets—a popular brand of inexpensive, “no precooking required” dry lasagna sheets in the UK—I was able to achieve excellent results.
They work fine. Here is an example of a vegetarian lasgana where I use them. The key is to make sure that there is plenty of well-seasoned liquid for them to absorb. You dont need to parboil them.
I’ll bring up Americas Test Kitchen (also known as Cooks Illustrated) once more. Although they enjoy the no-boil sheets, they have encountered some of the same issues that have already been discussed here. They advise soaking the sheets in hot tap water for ten minutes prior to use in order to address those problems. Ive done it, it works great.
Although I much prefer the flavor of fresh lasagna sheets, there doesn’t seem to be much of a difference in taste between the various types of dried sheets that are labeled as “no precooking required.” But I’ve discovered that they differ greatly by brand.
The only thing I would add is that, depending on the brand and number of layers you use, it may take some trial and error to get a creamy texture with “no-precooking-required” ones because they absorb varying amounts of liquid, which can result in a stodgy (but still delicious) finish. For me, adding more sauce and reducing the number of layers by one has been successful.
In the fifteen years that I have been making lasagne, I have never experienced an issue with instant sheets.
I use the sheets, meat sauce, and cheese sauce. I cook it in a moderate oven for about 30 to 35 minutes, and I test the doneness by piercing a knife through the layers. Occasionally it will need an extra 5-10 minutes cooking time.
While I adore fresh pasta for other purposes, I’ve discovered that dried sheets work much better to maintain the shape of lasagna!
Do not boil the no-boil lasagna even for a minute. I did this and ruined every noodle. I can not unstuck them.
I decided to boil first, following the directions on the package, for ten minutes the next time after using dry sheets in the past and finding them to be tough in spots where the sauce may not have reached them. The majority of them became stuck together and ended up being about 20%50% unusable, which caused a right amount of pain. Give up – I will use fresh next time.
It is all about the sauce and the time. When baking lasagna, if you are boiling your pasta sheets or using fresh ones, it will be done in about 30 minutes. However, it would take more than an hour if your sheets weren’t boiled. I’m making a ragù with a lot of sauce; I’m using a little bit more. I also use a bechamel-ricotta mixture, which I also use liberally. I make the bechamel sauce first, then stir in the ricotta until it’s smooth. When ricotta cheese and sauce are combined, the sauce becomes extremely smooth (not typically grainy) and you have extra sauce that your pasta sheet can absorb.
It was concrete when I made mine without boiling the pasta sheets. I advise you to parboil them for two to five minutes so they are tender but not cooked. But I am no professional, its just my opinion. Hope it was good use.
Pasta noodles without cooking are preferable to those that need to be parboiled. They shouldnt need to be soaked or cooked or parboiled. They DO need to be completely covered in sauce.
I use more of the tomato sauce layers and less of the ricotta and Bechamel layers to achieve this. I no longer drain the juice from my canned chopped tomatoes as I used to, and I also no longer drain the juice from my ground beef.
When the lasagna is cooking, you can test it by poking it several times with a fork to see how long it takes to bake until the noodles are tender and the dish is thoroughly heated.
The largest problem I’ve encountered with the no-cook noodles is that it’s challenging to locate disposable foil pans that will fit the noodles without breaking them. I produce a large quantity at once (10 liters of tomato sauce, 5 1lb Tubs ricotta etc. ).
Though I’ve never seen them, there are supposedly precooked lasagne noodles that are flat and don’t have a ruffled edge. My family and friends love my lasagne.
In addition, I wait to bake the lasagne until that evening if I plan to serve it. I usually freeze them without baking. To ensure that the plastic is removed and the foil is replaced before placing it in the oven, I placed plastic film on top and then foil with a taped-on note. In a convection oven, the frozen lasagna takes at least an hour to cook (9×11″ pan). Id never go back to sticky wet lasagne noodles.
I only ever use the packaged sheets. I cook them in a frying pan, not a saucepan. Start with hot tap water, no salt or oil added. About 3/4 heat. Five minutes later, I slide between the sheets with an egg lifter. Stops them sticking together. After ten minutes, take the sheet off the stove, leaving it out one at a time, and place it on paper towels to absorb any leftover water. Works well every time.
Boiling the noodles is definitely my least favorite part of making lasagna.
I used to purchase the no-boil noodles until I realized that the instructions were the same but that the no-boil noodles required twice as much sauce, and that I was paying more for a smaller package.
My frugal brain began to churn over this, so a few years ago I decided to see if I could get the same results using regular noodles and doubling the sauce for lasagna as I could with the more expensive no-boil noodles and double the sauce.
To my surprise, it seemed to work pretty well!
After that, I did some research and found that there is really no difference between regular lasagna noodles and no-boil lasagna noodles other than the fact that the latter are slightly pre-boiled before drying.
I’ve tried a few different approaches to my favorite lasagna recipes before settling on one that seems to work incredibly well for me. It easily saves me 15 minutes of prep time—and a lot of frustration!
To be completely honest, I think the meal tastes more “starchy” when the noodles aren’t boiled first, but no one in our family seems to mind.
That being said, I think I would boil the noodles first if I were preparing this for company or for someone else.
